Dr. Nay Win Maung
c/o MHK,

You have every right to express your view, your opinion, you have your rights , the democratic rights that every human being is talking about thet every human being is longing for.

I have no right to ask you “ who the hell you are or what the hell you are or this or that which are against or opposite to human rights.
Because I respect you as fellow human being. If somebody doesn’t know or accept you or anybody as human being let’s say that is his right as well and say good luck to him. As long as you and I respect each other as human and the human rights, that is more than good enough for me.

If there is peace in the world. If everybody agrees with everybody. If nobody has any conflicting view or opinion against other. I can guarantee you, assure you that this world which is called Planet Earth will stop turning and crash, disappear into the obit.

I just want to start from the following ;

“ The given situation of Myanmar politics in fact needed a smart strategy and clear vision. The best way could be encapsulated as below.”

It took me this long to publish this reply . Because I have done a very long reply, but in the end I decided, to reply to these six points only. They are nice but not feasable should I say.

“ 1. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi should provide a good will gesture by means of letting General Than Shwe get the way out by saying yes to the constitution”

If Ma Su Kyi could think half as much as you can think. as longas at least 10 years ago, it would be great. “ Pyinyar Shi Thadi Phyit Khe or Atutt Kyuu Baloo Phyit ”. These two Myanmar sayings are meant for Ma SU Kyi, I think.

“ letting General Than Shwe get the way out by saying yes to the constitution.” How thoughtful of you to say such a thing. Whether Ma Su Kyi says Yes or No to the constitution the show will go on. What is Ma Su Kyi anyway? Do you think Gen Than Shwe is at the mercy of Ma Su Kyi or what? Has she got the power for somebody to live or die? Gen Than Shwe does not use that power even if he had that. . If he had used it Ma Su Kyi had died long ago, her bones are the powder by now. She is well protect by Gen Than Shwe. She should thank him instead. Lucky Ma Su Kyi had not been charged for treason if she is a Myanmar, she should be deported if she is a foreigner (British) to England. Wales and Scotland may not want her.

If you expect demonstrations during these days, make sure Ma Su Kyi lead them from the front. Tell her not to hide in her own house. Because she loves confrontations. She loves seeing blood. She loves seeing fire.

Talking about Gen Than Shwe, he is an old man, his days are numbered. He had nothing more to lose and nothing more to gain, do you understand what I mean ? The future is in the hands of the young generals, if Ma Su Kyi wants to confront them that is her choice. Don’t let any one confront SPDC on her behalf.

“ 2. Again, Daw Aung San Suu Kyi should endorse the constitution so as to make sure the fate of NLD.”

Ma Su Kyi is not even an elected member of anything. Has she got the right to cast the vote or not may still be the question. As ordinary person, she has a right to vote, she has a right not to vote. She can say Yes, she can say No. There is a limit what she can or cannot do.

My suggestion is she should quit as leader of NLD, give young people a chance. Because young general are coming up from the other side. She should quit the politic. NLD is suffering because of her. People are suffering because of her. Myanmar is suffering because of her., business community is suffering because of her. She should go back to England and try to be the Prime Minister of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

“ 3. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and NLD must focus the election especially to make sure NLD being not to be disenfranchised- instead of the referendum.”

NLD should dismiss her, expel her from the party, because she has her own interest, she is not acting in the interest of the party, not in the interest of the people , not in the interest of the nation. NLD leaders should know by now. What NLD can do or what it cannot do.

“ 4. In order to make sure the genuine election results and strong opposition, NLD must pronounce that they are going to contest only half of the seats of the both chambers (better to take part at the non ethnic constituencies) – in a way sending a signal to the regime that the objective is just to be merely the opposition.”

“ Genuine election results” what do you mean? Do you mean to say elections are not election if opposition do not win? Do you mean to say no matter how free and fair the elections are, as long as opposition does not win you cannot accept the genuine result? You already had your preconceived election results in advanced .

What are you suggesting, are you mad or what ? Even NLD becomes a legal party in future elections they have only 330 seats remember? Half of that is only 165 out of 330 seats. That is, if NLD wins allcontested seats.

Your suggestion for NLD to take part only at none ethnic constituencies, which means “ Burma Proper” in olden days unacceptable for many reasons People of all national races are living all over Myanmar in all divisions ,in all states and in all regions and in all zones.

Are you trying to treat all these people as immigrants and to move all these people back to where they came from originally, as though all of them are internally displaced people?

“ 5. NLD should learn to differentiate the genuine opposition politics and the confrontasia politic so as to build up the shadow government even at the first term“ .

If and when NLD take part in the elections , at least they can become partner to the coalition government of the future, let alone shadow cabinet or in your own words “shadow government.” They have all the opportunity. If they abandon their rights by not taken part, like they did in NC, that is nobody’s fault, but them.

Eh, ha, that’s more like it. opposing everything for the sake of opposing , in the name of opposing. NLD doesn’t know what to oppose or what not to oppose. They take pride in opposing anything everything whatever SPDC has done,like a
mad man.

NLD leadership is not democratic, Ma Su Kyi is their dictator. She likes noibody to dictate her4 but she will dictate others. NLD leadership becoming dictatorship. They cannot function without Ma Su Kyi, that is the fact. There are no men in the NLD who are men enough to run NLD. I very much like to know who is dictating Ma Su Kyi? He conscience and common sense?

“ 6. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi can strengthen her organization while serving as an opposition within those five years”

NLD is weak , very weak. It cannot live up to the peoples’ expectation. It is proven. NLD is surrounded by " Thinjan Amhyauts ". UIt is surround4ed by the town cryers. People inside Myanmar realised how they have been thoroughly used by the NLD. People realised that if NLD gets its way the nation will go back to 1950s Everybody has to run for their lives again.

NLD is a goner, so are their leaders, NLD is a thing of the past. Even it change to another name, to start again as a political party. I doubt there is anyone who wants to be the NLD candidate.

Somebody should read again Brig Gen Kyaw San meetings with Mr Gambari thoroughly, word by word, sentence by sentence. Because its worth it. I mean to say, the more you read it the more you understand, the more meaning come out.

Thunderbolts.